27 March 2013
BEST SHOT: JACKIE BROWN
Today, genre-pastiche superstar Quentin Tarantino turns 50, and Nathaniel R has accordingly selected the director's 1997 Jackie Brown as this week's Hit Me with Your Best Shot entry. A bold choice, given that I think most of us would likely first think of one of Tarantino's collaborations with Robert Richardson when it comes to the visually richest films of his career, but a wise choice as well: though Jackie Brown is typically the odd man out in most considerations of Tarantino's career (owing to it being adapted from an Elmore Leonard novel), it is probably the most sophisticated and mature of all his movies, as cinema and as narrative (and this also probably owes to it being adapted from Elmore Leonard). Besides, Guillermo Navarro might not be a Robert Richardson, but he's hardly a slouch in the rich visuals department.
The film might not be as playful as a Kill Bill, Vol. 2, for example, but re-watching it for the first time in several years, I was struck by just how complex the imagery actually was; enough so that picking one single shot that summed it all up was as enjoyable hard as it has been in all the years that this series has been going on. Not least because some of the finest shots gain a great deal of their impact from being echoes of earlier shots, or because of the relationship between shots in a scene (this was also the first time I watched anything cut by the great Sally Menke since her untimely 2010 death, and boy, talk about being missed).
In the end, I went with something that I can't help but feel might have fallen on the wrong side of obvious, but the more I thought about it, the more that it encapsulates everything that makes Jackie Brown unique among Tarantino's films and rewarding in its own right: the low-key but nevertheless densely packed visuals, the unusually adult perspective, the relative naturalism. And it happens to be one of the moments on which the whole film hinges: at 45 minutes into the film, when bail bondsman Max Cherry (Robert Forster) first catches a glimpse of Pam Grier's titular Jackie, the sun around which everything else in the movie orbits. He's come to prison to bail her out and take her home, and he walks over to the prison gate to watch her coming out.
Then he sees her, and the focus shifts - this is hugely important.
For it is right at this point that everything coalesces and a film that has shifted between characters and locations somewhat loosely (though it all makes sense at the end, the way that Tarantino introduces plotlines and characters feels deliberately shaggy) takes the shape that it will take from here own out: Jackie Brown is going to make all the decisions for everybody, but especially for Max, who has just fallen in love with this marvelous woman, just from the way she carries herself, steady of pace and straight-backed even as she leaves her first-ever stay in jail. It helps, undoubtedly, that Navarro slights this long cement walk with such overt Romanticism - the one key light in the back, a certain mistiness in the air.
Accidentally or not, it recalls to my mind the iconic final shot of The Third Man, and given Tarantino's penchant for quoting movies, I won't say that's impossible: certainly, both shots contain a similar narrative about a grubby sort of Everyman, and the camera behind them, staring longingly at a steel-willed woman. But Jackie Brown is nowhere near as cynical about it: we don't merely feel awe for Jackie in this shot, though it's one of the images in the whole movie that best showcases her (and Grier's) strength - even as a little dot, she can be the visual anchor for a whole frame! It's also a moment that places her in such a glamorised context that we can't help but fall in love with her a little bit too, and that makes it a perfect symbol of a film that frequently functions as nothing more or less than Tarantino's Valentine to a legendary actress.
The film might not be as playful as a Kill Bill, Vol. 2, for example, but re-watching it for the first time in several years, I was struck by just how complex the imagery actually was; enough so that picking one single shot that summed it all up was as enjoyable hard as it has been in all the years that this series has been going on. Not least because some of the finest shots gain a great deal of their impact from being echoes of earlier shots, or because of the relationship between shots in a scene (this was also the first time I watched anything cut by the great Sally Menke since her untimely 2010 death, and boy, talk about being missed).
In the end, I went with something that I can't help but feel might have fallen on the wrong side of obvious, but the more I thought about it, the more that it encapsulates everything that makes Jackie Brown unique among Tarantino's films and rewarding in its own right: the low-key but nevertheless densely packed visuals, the unusually adult perspective, the relative naturalism. And it happens to be one of the moments on which the whole film hinges: at 45 minutes into the film, when bail bondsman Max Cherry (Robert Forster) first catches a glimpse of Pam Grier's titular Jackie, the sun around which everything else in the movie orbits. He's come to prison to bail her out and take her home, and he walks over to the prison gate to watch her coming out.
Then he sees her, and the focus shifts - this is hugely important.
For it is right at this point that everything coalesces and a film that has shifted between characters and locations somewhat loosely (though it all makes sense at the end, the way that Tarantino introduces plotlines and characters feels deliberately shaggy) takes the shape that it will take from here own out: Jackie Brown is going to make all the decisions for everybody, but especially for Max, who has just fallen in love with this marvelous woman, just from the way she carries herself, steady of pace and straight-backed even as she leaves her first-ever stay in jail. It helps, undoubtedly, that Navarro slights this long cement walk with such overt Romanticism - the one key light in the back, a certain mistiness in the air.
Accidentally or not, it recalls to my mind the iconic final shot of The Third Man, and given Tarantino's penchant for quoting movies, I won't say that's impossible: certainly, both shots contain a similar narrative about a grubby sort of Everyman, and the camera behind them, staring longingly at a steel-willed woman. But Jackie Brown is nowhere near as cynical about it: we don't merely feel awe for Jackie in this shot, though it's one of the images in the whole movie that best showcases her (and Grier's) strength - even as a little dot, she can be the visual anchor for a whole frame! It's also a moment that places her in such a glamorised context that we can't help but fall in love with her a little bit too, and that makes it a perfect symbol of a film that frequently functions as nothing more or less than Tarantino's Valentine to a legendary actress.
4 comments:
Just a few rules so that everybody can have fun: ad hominem attacks on the blogger are fair; ad hominem attacks on other commenters will be deleted. And I will absolutely not stand for anything that is, in my judgment, demeaning, insulting or hateful to any gender, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or religion. And though I won't insist on keeping politics out, let's think long and hard before we say anything particularly inflammatory.
Also, sorry about the whole "must be a registered user" thing, but I do deeply hate to get spam, and I refuse to take on the totalitarian mantle of moderating comments, and I am much too lazy to try to migrate over to a better comments system than the one that comes pre-loaded with Blogger.
Marvelous write-up. I definitely considered this shot for my pick too.
ReplyDeleteI think it's true that Jackie Brown is his most sophisticated film. He's a great screenwriter, certainly, and he's instilled so much of himself and the legacy of Grier's earlier films to make this film original (in the Tarantino-esque sense of the word) but you trace the signs back to the roots and it's clear they were originated in someone else's head. It has a poise and structure that sets it apart from all his other films.
As for Menke, well, yes, as Django proved she's badly missed. When I think of editing in Jackie Brown, I always think of the way she sets up the money exchange. It's an obvious showcase of Editing with a capital E, but sometimes these kind of moments stand out because they're just that great.
I've long considered it the best film of Tarantino's career, and quite possibly the best U.S. movie of the 90's, personally.
ReplyDeleteGod, Forester is amazing in it.
@Brian,
ReplyDeleteIt's pretty great alright. I'd love to see QT adapt more Elmore personally. I've been on a kick of reading his books over the last few months and there are tons of great stories to adapt.
Great example from QT's best film. The look on Robert Forster's face in that moment totally sells what Max is feeling. I agree that the entire scene is set up to show what type of movie this is, and their romance carries the rest of the story.
ReplyDelete