09 April 2016

ANIMAL BEHAVIOR

One of the few brand-name directors of animated features in the 21st Century, Hosoda Mamoru got that way through a most curious combination of radicalism and comforting familiarity. His 2006 international breakthrough, The Girl Who Leapt Through Time, is a perfect example: it's a nervy time-travel sci-fi tale of a sort that seemed positively revolutionary in the West (I presume, on no evidence, that it was less so in Japan), while being basically a comforting throwback to the brainer sort of midcenutry speculative fiction (it comes by this honestly, at least, being based on a 1967 novel). Nine years and three films later, that aspect of his career reaches its apex, maybe: The Boy and the Beast, which has the important distinction of being the only one of Hosoda's films to date which has no other credited writers than the director himself, is almost entirely devoid of meaningfully original ideas. But the way in which it packages its highly familiar content is utterly beguiling, enough to make its stock parts glisten.

So: a parentless child is taken away to a magical Otherworld where he learns important lessons and grows as a person, finding a comfortable slot in that world while always remaining importantly separate from it. That whole thing. The genius of it is in the details, of course, which start with 9-year-old Ren (Miyazaki Aoi) as the boy whose mother has just succumbed to an illness, and who runs away rather than ending up shunted with some barely-known relatives. On a lonely Tokyo night Ren crosses paths with two robed figures, visiting the human world from the beast world, which can only be accessed through a magical alleyway. These are the bear-like Kumatetsu (Yakusho Koji) and the monkey-like Tatara (Oizumi Yo), the former being one of two candidates to become lord of the beast realm once the current occupant of that seat, the rabbit-like Soshi (Tsugawa Masahiko), ascends to godhood. Kumatetsu, as we learn in the striking, gorgeous prologue, all in silhouettes and firelight, is a loner and lazy bully, and in order to prove his worthiness to take the mantle of leadership, he must first prove that he can train an apprentice in the ways of his fighting styles. With nothing better to do, Ren elects to chase the bear-man back to the beast world, forcing himself into the role of disciple, and the two clash over every tiny thing the might for several years, as Ren, renamed Kyuta, grows to young adulthood (Sometani Shota takes over the role), and Kumatetsu grows ever so marginally less lazy and arrogant.

Take out the magical realm of humanlike animals (or animalistic humans; I'm not sure that it's a distinction worth making), and this is obviously every "gruff man finds his heart thawed by the capricious orphan/orphan grows to self-sufficiency under the tutelage of a snappish father figure who secretly loves him" story in the history of world literature. Adding a layer of the fantastic helps to color that in a little bit, but there's only so much that even a petulant bear-man can do to move the needle on this particular scenario. Still, there's something to be said for playing the classic old songs particularly well, and The Boy and the Beast is absolutely a strong and appealing iteration of the basic form: the two leads (and really all of the characters, but there's no doubt who we're meant to care about the most) are drawn as bold cartoon characters in big swaths of solid colors, but also with a highly malleable flexiblity around the face that makes them particularly open emotionally for our sympathy and frustration, as the script demands it. It's almost unnervingly easy to get wrapped up in these characters' stories, and to find the way they play out to be enormously gratifying as a result.

In fact, the point where The Boy and the Beast becomes the least successful, to my eyes at least, is exactly where it pushes hardest against the foreordained boilerplate of its genre: there's a development that takes the grown-up Ren/Kyuta back to the human world for chunks of time, and in addition to being vaguely suspicious as a plot development (it's made somewhat clear that hopping between worlds isn't just something you can do whenever), it adds wrinkles and complications that Hosoda's script isn't particularly well-suited to investigate. It would be inappropriately spoilery to go into much detail; let it suffice to say that there are ways of complicating surrogate father/son relationships that are elegant and character-driven, and there are ways that are contrived. It knots up Ren's development as a character while largely ignoring Kumatetsu's, and leaves a potentially rich narrative line comparing Ren's life with another, sadder adopted child to be largely an exercise in implying emotional resonance beneath a thick swath of ginned-up conflict. Though I will cop to forgiving all the film's sins when it finds a way to work its shaggy plot add-ons back into a wholly weird and phantasmagorical climactic battle on the streets of the human world with the giant shadow of an invisible whale. I think that comes close enough to describing it accurately.

The point being, anyway, that the film's missteps are concentrated and backloaded, while its strengths are scattered all about with a amiable looseness. The opening sequence, by far the film's most familiar, is the most charming, funniest, and most brightly-paced; the sudden chronological jump in the middle of the film imbalances it just enough to make it interesting and ambitious. Plus, the whole movie is quite lovely to look at: besides the highly expressive characters, The Boy and the Beast boasts some marvelous backgrounds, with the inky, strong shades of the human world replaced with warmly-colored storybook paintings in the beast world, a simple shift in visual cues that gives the film an exaggerated boost in narrative clarity and emotional resonance. It's easy to fall in love with the world depicted onscreen, which is maybe the film's best strength: the imaginative elements of the character design make this all elaborate fantasy, but the cozy tangibility of the backgrounds make it all surprisingly homey. That's the most comforting thing about a most comforting film, and also the best way that it aligns us to the characters and makes us feel like we're taking part in their lives. None of this is at all groundbreaking or unimaginably sophisticated, but it works so very well to make for an involving, admirable family film.

8/10

8 comments:

  1. The pacing really does go badly awry leading into that false climax, but god is the real climax ever dazzling. I thought the film overall had less warmth, detail, and richness of character than Wolf Children (or even TGWLTT), but really if Hosoda only ever makes films as good as this one for the rest of his career I don't think anybody involved could be unhappy about it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. How does it compare to Hosoda's other films?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I liked it more than Girl Who Leapt Through Time less than Summer Wars. And I haven't seen Wolf Children, which arguably invalidates every opinion I have ever expressed in re: anime.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am eager to see this film, so I have mostly refrained from reading the review, but let me just encourage everyone to see Wolf Children forthwith. It's wonderful, the closest thing to My Neighbor Totoro that anyone other than Ghibli has made, but not some slavish imitation or anything. The whole middle hour is essentially a montage of snippets about growing up and motherhood that are highly imaginative, creatively edited, and just achingly beautiful. Honestly, it put me in mind of The Tree of Life. The ending is a bit of a letdown after that, but still: If anyone is going to take up the mantle of Miyazaki (and I realize this question/desire is contentious, and more pressure than anyone needs), I think it's going to be Mamoru Hosoda.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My favorite things Hosoda's ever done are actually two episodes of a cartoon that aired back in 2003. They're quite different from his feature films; Hosoda's work there very closely resembled the work of Edward Yang, who Hosoda does acknowledge as an influence.

    As much as I like Wolf Children, I kind of wish Hosoda go in a different direction than his recent films. He's unbelievably adept at working with a more somber, slower kind of film than this, and I'd like to see him try it again. If The Boy and the Beast is the kind of film he would rather make, then I hope he does, but his older stuff really gets to me in a way that this and even Wolf Children didn't.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yeah, his Digimon short films (which were chopped up with another short and made into the by-all-accounts lousy Digimon: The Movie) are actually really good. That first one, which is 20 minutes long, has hardly any dialogue, and is set to Ravel's Bolero, actually really made me think of Edward Yang in its view of the city at night as well, and it was great to hear him cite Yang as an influence. I haven't watched his One Piece movie yet, though.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was actually thinking of the episodes he did for Magical Doremi, but I like his Digimon films too.

    I haven't seen his One Piece film either, but I've heard that some people think it's a metaphor for his time at Studio Ghibli and the villain is supposed to be a stand-in for everything Hosoda didn't like about Hayao Miyazaki. I don't know if Hosoda's said anything on that himself.

    ReplyDelete

Just a few rules so that everybody can have fun: ad hominem attacks on the blogger are fair; ad hominem attacks on other commenters will be deleted. And I will absolutely not stand for anything that is, in my judgment, demeaning, insulting or hateful to any gender, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or religion. And though I won't insist on keeping politics out, let's think long and hard before we say anything particularly inflammatory.

Also, sorry about the whole "must be a registered user" thing, but I do deeply hate to get spam, and I refuse to take on the totalitarian mantle of moderating comments, and I am much too lazy to try to migrate over to a better comments system than the one that comes pre-loaded with Blogger.